Blog

How to tell if your SEO agency is actually doing anything

An old desk phone and a blank notepad on a worn shop counter

You pay an SEO agency every month. Each month a PDF arrives with charts that go up and to the right, and your phone rings about as often as it did last year. You suspect something is off, but you can't say what, because you don't know what the agency was supposed to do in the first place.

One construction owner on Reddit put it this way: "I definitely don't know how much is truly done." Another owner described paying a "$1,000 onboarding fee" and a "$1,500/month SEO retainer", roughly $17,500 over 11 months, before asking the same question.

You can answer that question yourself in about an hour, without learning SEO, as long as you know what to ask for and where to look. This is the checklist I'd use if I were in your seat.

Ask for a list of the work, in plain English

Start with one email: "What did you change on my website and my Google profile last month? Please list each change and the page or setting it was on."

A working agency can answer that the same day, because the list already exists. It looks something like this:

  • Rewrote the title and description on the water heater repair page.
  • Added two new service pages: drain cleaning and sump pump installation.
  • Fixed the business hours on Yelp and two directories so they match Google.
  • Uploaded eight new job photos to the Google profile.
  • Replied to four new reviews.

Every line on that list is something you can open and check. If the answer comes back as "ongoing optimization", "authority building" or "technical improvements" with nothing you can click, you have learned something. A plumber in this thread asked what $3,500 a month would get him and was told "local pack visibility" and "authority building." Neither phrase names a piece of work he could open and check.

Check your Google Business Profile yourself

For most local businesses, the Google profile (the listing with your map pin, hours and reviews) brings in more calls than the website does. It is also the easiest place to check whether anyone has touched anything.

Sign in to your profile on Google Search or Maps and look at:

  • Photos. When was the last photo uploaded, and by whom?
  • Updates (posts). Are there any from the last two months?
  • Reviews. Has every recent review had a reply?
  • Services and categories. Do they match what you actually sell, and do they include the jobs you want more of?
  • Performance. This tab shows calls, direction requests and website clicks from your profile. Note the numbers for the last three months.

If the agency's report says "GBP optimization" and the profile looks exactly like it did in spring, ask about it.

Count calls and form leads, not rankings

Rankings are the number agencies like to show, because they move often and look good on a chart. What pays you is a phone call, a quote request or someone walking in, so those are the numbers to track.

One UK owner shared his agency report in this post: "five tracked local keywords ranking around positions 35–45, with none in the top 10. It records two quote requests and one contact." Position 35 is the fourth page of Google. Nobody calls from there.

Ask your agency to report these every month, next to the same month last year:

  • Calls from the Google profile.
  • Website form submissions and quote requests.
  • Direction requests, if customers come to you.
  • Calls from the website, if you have call tracking.

You don't need perfect attribution. You need the same handful of numbers, measured the same way, every month. If the agency can't or won't give you those, the rankings report is filling the gap.

Make sure you own every account

This one matters even if the agency is good. Check that these are in your name, with your email as the owner:

  • Your domain name, at the registrar where you renew it.
  • Your Google Business Profile. You should be the primary owner and the agency a manager.
  • Google Analytics and Google Search Console for your site.
  • Your website hosting, or at least a full copy of the site you can take with you.

An owner in a website thread put it bluntly: "Don't allow a builder to hold you hostage. It's your website. You paid." If the agency created these accounts under its own email, ask them to transfer ownership now, while the relationship is friendly. It takes a few minutes for each.

Know what a fair timeline looks like

"SEO takes time" is true and gets abused. The UK owner above described agencies that "just keep you paying with "SEO takes time" for as long as they can."

Here is how I think about timing. Fixes to your Google profile and your website (correct categories, hours, service pages, photos, matching business details across directories) are visible within weeks, because you can see they were done. Ranking higher for competitive searches in your town can take months, and nobody controls it fully. Google's own help page says local results are based on "relevance, distance, and prominence", and distance is simply how far the searcher is from you.

So the fair deal looks like this: the agency shows you finished work every month from the start, and you agree on a checkpoint date when calls and leads should start moving. If nothing has moved by then and the agency can't explain why with specifics, that's your answer.

Red flags worth acting on

Some answers should end the conversation quickly:

  • A guarantee of first place on Google. Google says there is "no way to request or pay for a better local ranking." An agency that guarantees it is guessing or doing something risky.
  • Bought reviews or links. Fake reviews can get your profile suspended. If someone offers to "boost" your reviews, say no.
  • No access to your own accounts. See the section above.
  • Charges after you cancel. One owner on r/SEO told them to pause "and then I just got eight $300 charges from them." Get the cancellation terms in writing before you sign anything.
  • Reports with no list of work. Charts without a changelog don't tell you what you paid for.

What to do if the answers are bad

Don't cancel in anger before you have your accounts back. Do it in this order:

  1. Move ownership of the domain, Google profile, analytics and Search Console to your own email.
  2. Download a copy of the website, or confirm you can export it.
  3. Read your contract for the notice period and send the cancellation in writing.
  4. Watch your card statement for the next two months.

Then write down what you actually want from the next person: more calls from your service area, for the jobs you make money on, with a monthly list of work you can check. That one sentence filters out most of the bad proposals.

How I report on my own work

I run Nearhawk on my own, so the person who does the work is the person who writes the report. Every month you get a short plain-English list: what I did, why I did it, and what I'll do next. Beside it are the numbers above: calls, form leads and direction requests from your profile and site. The local SEO and AI search service explains exactly what is included each month, and the pricing page shows what it costs and how to cancel.

If you'd rather have someone check your current setup first, the free Local Visibility Audit looks at your Google profile, your site and how you show up in AI answers, and tells you what I'd fix first. You get it in writing, and you don't have to get on a sales call.

FAQ

How long should I give an SEO agency before judging it?

Judge the work from the first month: you should get a list of finished changes you can check. Judge results on a date you both agree on before you start. Fixes to your Google profile and site show quickly. Rankings for competitive searches can take months, so agree on which numbers should move and by when.

What should a monthly SEO report include?

A list of the work done, each item tied to a page or setting you can open. Then calls, form leads and direction requests compared with the same month last year, plus what is planned next month. Rankings can be in there too, but they shouldn't be the only thing.

Can an agency guarantee I'll be first on Google Maps?

No. Google says there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking, and distance from the searcher is one of the main factors. An honest agency promises the work, the schedule and the reporting, not the position.

Is it a bad sign if my agency owns my Google Business Profile?

It is a risk, even if they mean well. You should be the primary owner of your profile, domain and analytics, and the agency should have manager access. Ask for the transfer while things are friendly.

Want me to look at yours?

The free Local Visibility Audit checks your Google profile, your website and how you show up in AI answers. You get a written list of what I'd fix first.

No sales call. I read every request myself and reply in writing.

Get the free audit